- FluorideMind@lemmy.worldEnglish4 hours
They act like we have this big problem with 3d printed guns. This is about control not safety.
- Assassassin@lemmy.dbzer0.comEnglish5 hours
Wow, they are doing so much to stop guns from getting into the wrong hands. I’m really glad the everyday issue of 3d printed guns will finally be solved.
Wait until they find out that you can make a shotgun with some galvanized pipe and a nail.
8 hoursAre 3d printed guns even a problem? This whole thing is just a way to destroy peoples ability to do anything on their own, or repair anything.
3D printing working, safe-to-handle and durable guns is a pretty complicated technical problem. Don’t need to be a genius to figure out that making 100% plastic guns is asking for trouble. Tiny explosion = big plastic cracky.
Meanwhile, any monkey can bash together pieces of scrap metal and produce a durable gun that way. And that was a thing long, long before 3D printers existed.
- 6 hours
Not nearly as much of a problem as real guns that’s for goddamn sure.
- Dookieman12@piefed.socialEnglish7 hours
Gosh, if only it were illegal to manufacture and sell weapons without a license, then we wouldn’t need all this.
- NarrativeBear@lemmy.worldEnglish8 hours
Video series worth a watch from 3D Printing Nurd.
These videos talk about the additive printing bill and how it essentially looking to make any “uncertified” 3d printer or even CNC machines illegal.
Strictest 3D Printing Regulation YET! California AB2047: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ax9zW0w_gY
3D Printing in California Can Be Saved! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGvvEuIPJxA
The FINAL Hearing in California: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6fpPStIAsY
- Marn@lemmy.dbzer0.comEnglish12 hours
I rember in the US police had an event where in an effort that has had some success getting guns off the street is they were paying $200 per gun you turned in, including ghost guns no questions asked. Some legend heard about the event and quickly made quite a few working guns out of 2"x4"s, metal plumbing pipe, and a nail. He only used basic tools like a drill and angle grinder from what I remember. The police had to pay him too, but I think they changed the rules after
One problem the left especially the global left outside the US has when they talk about gun control they flat out do not understand how things work when so many people want something as much as people want guns in the US. Also how hard it would be to actually change the constitution. They were not able to stop people smoking weed or drinking alcohol either. It’s going to have to be a major societal shift. I think there’s a good chance we will see that in the next 50 years.
I support gun control wherever it’s shown to actually work but a lot laws are being pushed by either someone with an alternative motive like the 3D printer laws, or have actually no clue and just want to put another law that sounds good to
The 3D printer laws are really a micro manufacturing and surveillance law that appears to be being pushed by a billionaire and a company in bed with palantir. It could kill open source 3d printers that are the only reason we have 3d printers in the first place. The guns people make with 3D printers require major components from actual guns that you can leagly buy because the parts are not considered a gun.
- flandish@lemmy.worldEnglish10 hours
iirc some of the parts you need like the lower are considered guns, but your point still stands. the last paragraph, i mean. it’d just surveillance state horseshit with the added benefit of protecting corporate profits in an industry that was developed with public funds and innovation.
- buzz86us@lemmy.worldEnglish13 hours
This is just the dumbest thing ever… So I can’t print a grip for a camera?
- axh@lemmy.worldEnglish15 hours
When you consider how many students were shoot with 3d printed guns… Oh wait, those were all manufactured by a proper business, carry on then, we don’t want to interrupt big businesses.
- Cocodapuf@lemmy.worldEnglish18 hours
New laws in California and New York might stop people from 3D printing guns
It absolutely, positively, will not do that. If someone wants to print a gun, no legislation is going to stop them. It could at best, slow them down by maybe an hour, as they find, download and install different firmware for their printer.
If you want to prevent people from printing guns, you’ll need a different tactic, because that won’t do it.
- grue@lemmy.worldEnglish21 hours
This goes way, way beyond ‘guns.’ It is an assault on property rights and freedom of expression as concepts generally. It would fully outlaw Free Software firmware (which is what the entire 3D printer hobby, having started with the RepRap project, is based on!). It would cut the Maker movement as a whole off at the knees.
It’s absolute tyranny in ways entirely unrelated to guns themselves.
- DaddleDew@lemmy.worldEnglish23 hours
“might stop anyone from 3D printing guns”
I can guarantee you that it won’t even do that.
- mctoasterson@reddthat.comEnglish19 hours
It absolutely won’t do that. You know how many millions of early generation Prusa and Ender 3 printers are in the US? Many of these models have no internet connectivity whatsoever and print from SD card.
What that means is they will also try to incorporate spyware into your CAD and/or slicer software, which is even more invasive.
This is a anti-privacy bill.
- Ghoelian@piefed.socialEnglish5 hours
I don’t even understand how they imagine this will work. Most printers are certainly not powerful enough to do real 3d object detection. Even if they forced slicers to include this, just fork OrcaSlicer and take it back out. Actually a lot of printers run open source software as well, so we can just fork klipper of it ever comes to that.
- 12 hours
It won’t stop anyone buying or importing innocuous machinery parts like 2020 aluminium extrusions or GT2 belts either. There are mature generic 3D printer designs out there that outperforms RepRap i3 bedslingers.
- iocase@lemmy.zipEnglish20 hours
It’s like making a normal printer that’s mandated by the government to never print dicks
- DaddleDew@lemmy.worldEnglish17 hours
I mean normal printers will not let you print money. That’s what gave these idiots the idea to begin with I’d wager. But there are orders of magnitude in difference in difficulty between making a piece of software capable of autonomously recognizing a few existing designs of dollar bills and one that can tell a working gun part that can take a shape that can vary almost infinitely from other objects that can also take nearly infinite shapes.
- elucubra@sopuli.xyzEnglish14 hours
They don’t recognize bills. They recognize a pattern of tiny yellow rings in the bills, the Eurion constellation, which can barely be seen by the eye. This supposedly will stop copiers and printers from scanning or printing any document that has these.
Bypassing these is trivial.
- 42firehawk@fedinsfw.appEnglish15 hours
It’s not even a few existing designs… There is an exact pattern called the eurion constellation that all printers block. Then the process for printing each countries currency just involves placing a eurion constellation and you get the protection.
Its a single pattern that is very rigidly defined, to the point that many counterfeit bills that pass inspection shift one mark off by about a millimeter to get it printed.
Granted having worked at a bank when I found out was that the bill didn’t have the off color threads as well, but it almost was approved despite getting a close inspection.
- PattyMcB@lemmy.worldEnglish21 hours
It absolutely will not stop some people. But those are not the ones committing gun crimes
Not too sure about this but, um… Can’t you just print it offline?..
- Shaunhitorigoto@lemmy.zipEnglish13 hours
Well that’s the common problem I think we’re seeing everywhere now, everything HAS to be connected to the internet. Can’t connect to the internet? No playing video games on your playstation then, even if it’s single player coz that disk you bought doesn’t have the actual game files, it’s just an access key to the servers where the game is hosted! Can’t use your HP printer that has built in ink cartridge subscription, even though it’s still half full? That’s because you unsubscribed. Can’t use the seat heater in your new car? That’s cos we turned that fucking thing off by remotely connecting to the car’s OS. boohoo, pay up.
Soon we’ll be having toilet seats that won’t open because it’s connected to the internet and you missed your shitter subscription, and It’ll be disguised as some nonsense safety regulation that monitors you bowel movements for your well being or something i dunno.
- 8 hours
I wouldn’t be against my toilet monitoring my movements. But the data collected needs to be shared with my doctor only - since she could potentially do something useful with it.
- DigDoug@lemmy.worldEnglish21 hours
I’m no gun person, but you could easily make a gun on a lathe or a mill drill, too. Get a CNC one and you don’t even need to know how to use them.
Are we going to start fitting them with “you might be making a gun” detectors, too? Of course not.
Edit: Turns out they are… I choose to blame my ignorance on the paywall.
- grue@lemmy.worldEnglish21 hours
Are we going to start fitting [CNC lathes and mills] with “you might be making a gun” detectors, too? Of course not.
I’ve got some bad news for you about just how fucked-up these proposed laws actually are.
- PattyMcB@lemmy.worldEnglish21 hours
I’m pretty sure the law says any machine that takes sets of automated instructions, which includes CNC cutters and lathes
- 23 hours
You absolutely need to know how to use any machine tool. You can’t just download a file to a CNC mill and have it spit out a gun. I worked as a machinist when I was in college, it takes a lot of skill and talent to setup a CNC to make parts.
- SupraMario@lemmy.worldEnglish23 hours
You can’t load a file on a 3d printer and print a gun either…
On top of that, making a firearm is %100 legal.
- SupraMario@lemmy.worldEnglish10 hours
NY you can as long as you have a FFL or gunsmith license. Both are not super hard to get.
California you can without a license and you can make up to 3 a year.
- 22 hours
Yes it is 100% legal, I’ve done it myself. And there are actually single shot pistols you can download and print.
I’m not in anyway in favor of the legislation, just pointing out that machining a functioning anything isn’t as easy as you said.
- SupraMario@lemmy.worldEnglish10 hours
Those still require metal parts. No plastic is going to have enough strength to be used as a firing pin.
Not in California ever since they passed that bill that requires a DOJ-issued serial number on your home made firearm.
- SupraMario@lemmy.worldEnglish10 hours
Nope, you can still make up to 3 firearms a year in California without a FFL license.
- SupraMario@lemmy.worldEnglish10 hours
Even in NY it is %100 legal still, you have to print it with a serial and you must be licensed by the state to make a firearm (FFL or gunsmith).
- DigDoug@lemmy.worldEnglish22 hours
I know. I meant relative to using a manual machine.
You could make the same argument for 3D printers.
I can make a shotgun with a pipe, a tack, and a rubberband. Don’t even need fancy tools. And that’s especially crude. Prisoners in jail have made working firearms from toilet paper.
- Cort@lemmy.worldEnglish22 hours
Idk when you were in college, but tormach has come a long way with automation. It wouldn’t surprise me if someone had automated paths & tool changes and was able to pump out gun parts without much human intervention.
- 22 hours
Once the machine is set up yes, they can absolutely do that. That’s how they’re manufactured for the most part.
But the idea that any untrained, inexperienced person has the ability to physically setup, make jigs, indicate in said jigs, make a cad file, turn it into a cam program, load it into a machine, indicate in the stock, select the correct tooling and set it up, etc, etc, etc… It’s a magnitude more difficult than 3d printing, and the machines that do that kind of fully automated work costs in the millions.
- Cort@lemmy.worldEnglish22 hours
Honestly, the only difference would be the jigs and clamping, and making sure the tools are in the correct loading bay/socket. Everything else can be done by a 3rd party and distributed like it is with 3d printing. even the stock can be pre selected, it’s not any different than recommending abs over nylon or tpu.
I think the difference in magnitude only applies to the price of the machine.
- 20 hours
I’m not trying to be a dick, I just want to know if I’m talking to a layman or a professional.
- zarathustrad@lemmy.worldEnglish21 hours
Have you tried using an agentic AI?
Because people are already doing exactly that.
- 21 hours
They’re using agentic ai to autonomously program, physically setup and gauge, and then run parts? Where are they doing this and who are “people”?
- GarboDog@lemmy.worldEnglish14 hours
The overhang on that snake’s head and the tail’s end not even touching the build plate is borderline impossible, also yellow and black yet only showing a printer that has one yellow roll and we think that the machine can’t swap filaments either. So unrealistic :P
